1 PETER 3:13–22
WHAT DOES PETER MEAN WHEN HE SAYS, “BAPTISM NOW SAVES YOU”?
Peter has been teaching Christians how to live when the people around them do not share their faith.
Do good.
Do not repay evil for evil.
Seek peace.
Trust that God sees and hears.
Now Peter asks:
“Who is there to harm you if you are zealous for what is good?”
But Peter knows that doing good does not guarantee an easy life.
Jesus did good—and suffered.
Christians may do what is right—and suffer too.
That leads Peter into one of the most fascinating passages in his letter.
Before he finishes, he will mention:
suffering for righteousness,
giving an answer for our hope,
Christ's death,
the spirits in prison,
Noah and the flood,
baptism,
the resurrection,
and Jesus at God's right hand.
Some parts are difficult.
But we should begin with what is clear before trying to explain what is difficult.
3:13–14 — WHAT IF WE SUFFER FOR DOING RIGHT?
Peter asks:
“Now who is there to harm you if you are zealous for what is good?”
This is not a promise that Christians who do good will never suffer.
The very next verse says:
“But even if you should suffer for righteousness' sake, you will be blessed.”
Peter's readers apparently faced hostility because of their faith.
How should they respond?
“Have no fear of them, nor be troubled.”
Peter is echoing Isaiah 8:12–13.
Isaiah told God's people not to fear what others feared but to regard the LORD as holy.
Peter takes that language and applies it directly to Christ.
3:15 — “HONOR CHRIST THE LORD AS HOLY”
Peter says:
“But in your hearts honor Christ the Lord as holy…”
That is significant.
Peter has just drawn from a passage in Isaiah about honoring the LORD as holy.
Now he says Christians should honor Christ the Lord as holy.
The answer to fear of human beings is not pretending that people cannot hurt us.
It is recognizing that Christ is Lord.
Human beings do not have the final word.
Christ does.
“ALWAYS BE PREPARED TO MAKE A DEFENSE”
Peter continues:
“always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you…”
The Greek word translated “defense” is apologia.
It does not mean apologizing.
It means giving an answer or defense.
Our word apologetics comes from it.
But notice something easily overlooked.
Peter does not say:
Be prepared to win an argument.
He says:
“for the hope that is in you.”
Something about the Christian's life should raise a question.
These believers are suffering.
Yet they have hope.
Why?
Peter wants them ready to answer.
Our faith should be something we have thought about carefully enough that when someone asks why we believe, we can explain.
BUT HOW SHOULD WE ANSWER?
Peter immediately tells us:
“yet do it with gentleness and respect…”
That belongs to Christian apologetics too.
We can give the correct answer in the wrong spirit.
Peter does not authorize arrogance, ridicule, insults, or humiliation of people who disagree with us.
We should know what we believe.
We should know why we believe it.
And we should be careful about how we explain it.
Truth does not need rudeness to defend it.
3:16 — KEEP A GOOD CONSCIENCE
Peter continues:
“having a good conscience…”
Why?
So that:
“when you are slandered, those who revile your good behavior in Christ may be put to shame.”
Once again Peter returns to conduct.
A Christian's defense is not merely verbal.
There are two parts:
What we say.
How we live.
If our behavior contradicts our message, our argument loses much of its force.
Peter wants Christians to live so that accusations against them cannot be supported by the evidence.
3:17 — BETTER TO SUFFER FOR GOOD
Peter says:
“For it is better to suffer for doing good, if that should be God's will, than for doing evil.”
Again Peter distinguishes two kinds of suffering.
If I steal something and am punished, I am not suffering for Christ.
If I behave cruelly and people dislike me, that is not persecution.
If I insult someone and he becomes angry, I should not automatically congratulate myself for being persecuted for righteousness.
Peter is talking about suffering that comes despite doing what is right.
And now he gives the supreme example.
3:18 — CHRIST ALSO SUFFERED
“For Christ also suffered once for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, that he might bring us to God…”
This is the foundation beneath everything Peter has been saying.
Christ suffered unjustly.
He was:
“the righteous for the unrighteous.”
But His suffering accomplished something ours cannot.
“That he might bring us to God.”
That is a beautiful summary of the purpose of Christ's death.
Sin separated us from God.
Christ suffered for sins:
“once.”
His sacrifice does not need continual repetition.
Its purpose was reconciliation.
He brings us to God.
“PUT TO DEATH IN THE FLESH BUT MADE ALIVE IN THE SPIRIT”
Peter continues:
“being put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit…”
Jesus truly died.
But death did not hold Him.
The precise meaning of “in the spirit” is debated. It can be understood as a contrast between Christ's bodily death and His resurrection life, possibly involving the Holy Spirit.
We should be careful not to force more precision from the phrase than Peter gives us.
What is unmistakable is the movement:
Death → life.
And that movement leads Peter into the most difficult part of the passage.
3:19 — WHO WERE “THE SPIRITS IN PRISON”?
Peter says Christ:
“went and proclaimed to the spirits in prison…”
Who are these spirits?
When did Jesus preach to them?
What did He proclaim?
Christians have disagreed about this passage for centuries.
There are several major interpretations.
POSSIBILITY 1 — CHRIST PREACHED TO DEAD HUMAN BEINGS
Some understand Peter to mean that between His death and resurrection Jesus went to the realm of the dead and preached to people who had died in Noah's time.
But Peter does not tell us that they were offered a second opportunity for salvation.
That idea should not simply be assumed.
POSSIBILITY 2 — CHRIST PREACHED THROUGH NOAH
Another interpretation is that Christ, through the Spirit, preached through Noah to the people of Noah's generation while they were still alive.
They are now “spirits in prison.”
This connects reasonably well with Peter's reference to Noah, although the wording “went and proclaimed” makes the interpretation less than certain.
POSSIBILITY 3 — THE SPIRITS ARE REBELLIOUS SPIRITUAL BEINGS
Others understand the “spirits” as rebellious spiritual beings associated with the events surrounding Noah's generation.
This interpretation often connects Peter's language with Genesis 6:1–4 and Jewish traditions that developed around that passage.
In the New Testament, the word “spirits” without further qualification frequently refers to spiritual beings rather than dead human beings.
On this interpretation, Christ is not preaching an offer of salvation.
He is proclaiming His victory over defeated spiritual powers.
That fits particularly well with where Peter's argument ends in verse 22:
“angels, authorities, and powers having been subjected to him.”
There are good reasons why many interpreters find this view attractive.
But Peter does not stop and explain the identity of the spirits for us.
So we should distinguish between:
what Peter says
and
our attempt to reconstruct exactly what he means.
3:20 — THE DAYS OF NOAH
Peter identifies these spirits in connection with those:
“who formerly did not obey, when God's patience waited in the days of Noah, while the ark was being prepared…”
That brings us to Genesis 6–9.
The world was filled with wickedness.
God announced judgment.
But judgment did not come immediately.
God waited while Noah prepared the ark.
Peter calls this:
“God's patience.”
Then the flood came.
And Peter says:
“a few, that is, eight persons, were brought safely through water.”
Noah, his wife, his three sons, and their wives:
eight people.
Peter's readers were themselves a relatively small community surrounded by a much larger unbelieving society.
Noah therefore becomes an appropriate comparison.
Being in the minority does not determine whether someone is right with God.
3:21 — “BAPTISM…NOW SAVES YOU”
Now Peter makes the connection:
“Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you…”
This sentence has generated enormous controversy.
But before explaining it away—or using it as a slogan—we should simply allow Peter to say what he says.
He does not say:
“Baptism is merely a symbol that has nothing to do with salvation.”
He says:
“Baptism…now saves you.”
But Peter immediately explains what he does—and does not—mean.
“NOT AS A REMOVAL OF DIRT FROM THE BODY”
Peter says:
“not as a removal of dirt from the body…”
The saving significance of baptism is not found in the physical washing of skin.
There is nothing magical about water.
Simply becoming wet does not save anyone.
Peter specifically rejects that misunderstanding.
So what does he mean?
“AN APPEAL TO GOD FOR A GOOD CONSCIENCE”
Peter continues:
“but as an appeal to God for a good conscience…”
The Greek word eperōtēma can carry the sense of an appeal, request, or pledge.
That is why English translations differ.
Some say:
“an appeal to God for a good conscience.”
Others:
“the pledge of a good conscience toward God.”
The exact nuance is debated.
But either way, Peter is not describing an empty external ritual.
Baptism involves a person's response toward God.
It is not merely water touching the body.
WHAT ACTUALLY GIVES BAPTISM ITS SAVING SIGNIFICANCE?
Peter tells us:
“through the resurrection of Jesus Christ.”
This is crucial.
Peter does not place saving power in the water.
He places everything in Jesus Christ and His resurrection.
Remember how this letter began:
God “has caused us to be born again to a living hope through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead.”
Now Peter again connects salvation with the resurrection.
Christ saves.
Christ died for sins.
Christ rose from the dead.
And baptism is connected with our response to that saving work.
IS PETER SAYING BAPTISM EARNS SALVATION?
No.
Nothing in the passage describes baptism as a meritorious work by which we purchase salvation from God.
Peter has already grounded salvation in:
God's mercy,
Christ's blood,
Christ's suffering for sins,
and Christ's resurrection.
The person being baptized has not accomplished those things.
God has.
Baptism is a faith-response to what God has done.
That fits the wider New Testament picture.
On Pentecost Peter told people who believed his message:
“Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins.”
— Acts 2:38
Ananias told Saul:
“Rise and be baptized and wash away your sins, calling on his name.”
— Acts 22:16
Paul connected baptism with participation in Christ's death and resurrection in Romans 6:3–4 and Colossians 2:12.
The New Testament does not ask us to choose between:
faith OR baptism.
Nor does it ask us to choose between:
grace OR obedience.
Salvation is God's work.
Faith receives what God has done.
And in the apostolic preaching, baptism belongs naturally within the response of faith to Jesus Christ.
WHAT ABOUT THE THIEF ON THE CROSS?
This passage sometimes leads immediately to another question:
“What about the thief on the cross?”
The thief was saved by Christ.
That is clear.
But he died before Jesus' death, burial, resurrection, and the Great Commission command to make disciples and baptize them in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
The thief demonstrates that Jesus has authority to save.
He does not erase what the risen Jesus later commanded His disciples to preach and practice.
The question in 1 Peter 3 is not:
“Can God possibly save someone without baptism?”
God is sovereign.
The question is:
“What did Peter tell Christians about baptism?”
And his statement deserves to be heard:
“Baptism…now saves you…through the resurrection of Jesus Christ.”
3:22 — WHERE IS JESUS NOW?
Peter finishes the entire section by returning to Jesus:
“who has gone into heaven and is at the right hand of God…”
Jesus suffered.
Jesus died.
Jesus was raised.
Jesus ascended.
Jesus now sits at God's right hand.
And:
“angels, authorities, and powers having been subjected to him.”
Now the discussion about the “spirits in prison” fits into the larger picture.
Whatever difficulties we have interpreting verses 19–20, Peter's conclusion is perfectly clear:
Jesus won.
The spiritual powers are not His equals.
They are subject to Him.
FOLLOW PETER'S MOVEMENT
Look at the direction of the passage:
Christ suffered.
↓
Christ died for sins.
↓
Christ was made alive.
↓
Christ proclaimed His victory.
↓
Noah and the flood become Peter's comparison.
↓
Peter connects the flood with baptism.
↓
Baptism saves through Christ's resurrection.
↓
Christ ascended to heaven.
↓
Christ sits at God's right hand.
↓
Every spiritual authority is subject to Him.
Peter's main subject is not water.
His main subject is the victorious Jesus Christ.
NOAH, WATER, AND BAPTISM
Peter's comparison deserves another look.
Eight people were:
“brought safely through water.”
Then:
“Baptism, which corresponds to this…”
Peter uses the Greek word antitypon, from which we get antitype.
He sees a correspondence between the flood and Christian baptism.
But we should not make every detail of Noah's story correspond to something in baptism.
Peter gives us the connection himself.
Water marked the dividing point between an old world under judgment and a new beginning for Noah and his family.
Peter sees baptism in corresponding terms.
The Christian leaves the old life behind and enters a new life centered upon the resurrected Christ.
The power is not in the water.
The power is in the resurrection of Jesus Christ.
THE BIG PICTURE
This difficult passage actually has a remarkably simple center.
Peter is writing to frightened Christians.
People may threaten them.
People may slander them.
People may cause them to suffer.
Peter says:
Don't let fear determine your life.
Set Christ apart as Lord.
Be ready to explain your hope.
Speak with gentleness and respect.
Keep a good conscience.
Continue doing what is right.
And remember Jesus.
He suffered unjustly too.
But suffering did not defeat Him.
Death did not defeat Him.
The grave did not defeat Him.
Spiritual powers did not defeat Him.
He is risen.
He is at God's right hand.
Every authority is subject to Him.
That is why Christians can have hope even when they suffer.
SOMETHING TO THINK ABOUT
Sometimes we spend so much time arguing about:
“Baptism…now saves you”
that we miss the sentence immediately surrounding it.
Peter connects baptism with:
Jesus' death,
our appeal to God,
Jesus' resurrection,
Jesus' ascension,
and Jesus' reign.
Perhaps instead of beginning with:
“How can I make this verse fit what I have always been taught about baptism?”
we should begin with a simpler question:
“What did Peter actually say?”
Then we can compare Peter with Acts 2, Acts 22, Romans 6, Galatians 3, Colossians 2, and the rest of the New Testament.
We should not explain Peter away.
Neither should we make the water magical.
We should allow all of the text to speak.
Peter's words are:
“Baptism…now saves you…through the resurrection of Jesus Christ.”
The saving power belongs to Christ.
And Peter saw no contradiction between salvation by God's grace and calling people to respond to the risen Christ in baptism.
QUESTIONS TO THINK ABOUT
Why does Peter connect suffering for doing good with the suffering of Jesus?
What does it mean to “honor Christ the Lord as holy” in our hearts?
Are Christians commanded merely to know what they believe—or also to be able to explain why they believe it?
Why are gentleness and respect part of giving a Christian defense?
What does Peter clearly say about the “spirits in prison,” and what conclusions depend upon interpretation?
Why does Peter bring Noah into the discussion?
What correspondence does Peter see between Noah's flood and baptism?
What misunderstanding does Peter rule out when he says baptism is “not a removal of dirt from the body”?
What difference does it make whether eperōtēma is translated “appeal” or “pledge”? What remains clear either way?
Where does Peter locate the saving power connected with baptism?
How does 1 Peter 3:21 fit with Acts 2:38, Acts 22:16, Romans 6:3–4, and Colossians 2:12?
Why should we begin with Peter's actual words before trying to make the passage fit a theological system?
How does verse 22 answer the fear and suffering with which this section began?
NEXT STUDY
1 PETER 4:1–11 — “THEY ARE SURPRISED WHEN YOU DON'T JOIN THEM”
Peter now asks what happens when becoming a Christian actually changes the way we live.
Former friends may not understand.
“They are surprised when you do not join them in the same flood of debauchery, and they malign you.”
Then Peter makes another statement that requires careful attention:
“This is why the gospel was preached even to those who are dead…”
Does that mean the dead were given another opportunity to hear the gospel after death?
We will need to compare that carefully with what Peter has just said about the spirits in prison rather than assuming the two passages mean the same thing.
And Peter will finish with a wonderfully practical picture of Christian life:
Be self-controlled.
Pray.
Love one another earnestly.
Show hospitality without grumbling.
Use whatever gift God has given you to serve others.
All of it:
“in order that in everything God may be glorified through Jesus Christ.”
Return the HOME page
Reurn to 1-2 Peter page