Romans 5:12–21 — What Did Adam Change—and What Did Christ Change?
Romans 5:12 begins another major step in Paul's argument.
Until now Paul has talked about Abraham, faith, justification, peace with God, and reconciliation.
Now he goes much farther back.
Not to Abraham.
Not to Moses.
Not even to Israel.
Paul goes all the way back to Adam.
Why?
Because the problem Christ came to solve did not begin with Israel.
It began with humanity.
Paul is about to place two men side by side:
Adam and Christ.
Through one came sin and death.
Through the other come grace, righteousness, and life.
Let's follow Paul's comparison carefully.
Sin Entered Through One Man
Paul begins:
“Therefore, just as sin came into the world through one man, and death through sin…”
— Romans 5:12
Paul takes us back to Genesis 3.
God had warned Adam about death.
Adam disobeyed.
Sin entered the human story.
And with sin came death.
Paul continues:
“and so death spread to all men because all sinned.”
Every human being now lives in a world marked by sin and death.
And every one of us also sins.
The problem is universal.
That is why Paul's gospel must also reach beyond one nation.
The problem Christ came to solve is as old as Adam.
Before There Was Moses
Paul again asks us to think about chronology:
“for sin indeed was in the world before the law was given…”
— Romans 5:13
There was sin before Sinai.
There was death before Moses.
That matters.
If humanity's basic problem already existed before the Law was given, the Law could not be the origin of the problem.
Nor could Israel's possession of the Law by itself solve it.
Paul says:
“Yet death reigned from Adam to Moses…”
— Romans 5:14
Think about that period.
Adam.
Noah.
Abraham.
Isaac.
Jacob.
Joseph.
All lived before the Law of Moses.
And all lived under the shadow of death.
Humanity needed something greater than another law.
Humanity needed someone who could overcome what began with Adam.
Adam Was a “Type”
Then Paul says something surprising about Adam:
“Adam, who was a type of the one who was to come.”
— Romans 5:14
The one to come is Christ.
But how could Adam be a type of Christ?
Not because Adam and Jesus did the same thing.
Quite the opposite.
They are alike because the action of one man affected many others.
Adam's act brought terrible consequences.
Christ's act brings the opposite.
Paul will now compare them.
But he will also make sure we understand that Christ is far greater than Adam.
“The Free Gift Is Not Like the Trespass”
Paul says:
“But the free gift is not like the trespass.”
— Romans 5:15
Then:
“For if many died through one man's trespass, much more have the grace of God and the free gift by the grace of that one man Jesus Christ abounded for many.”
Notice Paul's repeated words:
free gift
grace
much more
Adam's act brought death.
Christ brings grace.
And Paul does not describe grace as barely repairing the damage.
He says it abounded.
Christ does more than simply bring us back to where Adam started.
Grace overwhelms the trespass.
Condemnation and Justification
Paul continues the contrast:
“For the judgment following one trespass brought condemnation, but the free gift following many trespasses brought justification.”
— Romans 5:16
One trespass began the terrible story.
Then came many trespasses.
Generation after generation sinned.
Yet God's answer to this mountain of human sin is:
the free gift.
And the result is:
justification.
Paul has returned to the subject he has been developing since Romans 3.
But now he places justification inside the largest possible story.
It is God's answer to a human problem reaching all the way back to Adam.
Two Reigns
Paul describes death almost as though it were a king:
“because of one man's trespass, death reigned through that one man…”
— Romans 5:17
Death reigned.
But then Paul gives us the other side:
“much more will those who receive the abundance of grace and the free gift of righteousness reign in life through the one man Jesus Christ.”
Notice the contrast:
Death reigned through Adam.
But through Christ:
people reign in life.
Paul's gospel is not merely about having our past sins erased.
It is about God's victory over the reign of sin and death.
That story began in Eden.
And Christ has entered that story to reverse what Adam brought into it.
One Trespass — One Act of Righteousness
Paul summarizes:
“Therefore, as one trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one act of righteousness leads to justification and life…”
— Romans 5:18
Then he says it another way:
“For as by the one man's disobedience the many were made sinners, so by the one man's obedience the many will be made righteous.”
— Romans 5:19
Here is Paul's contrast:
Adam — disobedience
Christ — obedience
Adam — condemnation
Christ — justification
Adam — death
Christ — life
The center of Paul's argument is not what humanity accomplished.
It is what these two representative men did.
One disobeyed.
One obeyed.
And Jesus' obedience changes everything.
What Does Paul Mean by “All”?
Verse 18 deserves careful reading:
“as one trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all men.”
Someone might read that sentence by itself and conclude that Paul teaches that every human being will finally be justified.
But we should not build a doctrine from one phrase without reading its context.
Just one verse earlier Paul described those who:
“receive the abundance of grace and the free gift of righteousness.”
— Romans 5:17
And throughout Romans Paul has repeatedly spoken about faith.
So we should allow Paul's whole argument to determine what he means rather than forcing one sentence to carry more than its context allows.
His central point here is the enormous reach of Christ's act compared with Adam's.
Adam's sin brought condemnation and death into the human story.
Christ's obedience opens justification and life.
Then Why Did the Law Come?
Paul now returns to the Law:
“Now the law came in to increase the trespass…”
— Romans 5:20
That may sound strange.
Wasn't the Law supposed to make things better?
Paul does not say the Law created sin.
Sin was already in the world.
He has just told us that.
But when God's commands clearly identify what is right and wrong, human rebellion becomes unmistakable transgression.
The Law exposes the seriousness of sin.
But Paul does not end there.
“Grace Abounded All the More”
Here comes one of the great statements in Romans:
“but where sin increased, grace abounded all the more.”
— Romans 5:20
Sin does not get the final word.
Paul continues:
“so that, as sin reigned in death, grace also might reign through righteousness leading to eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.”
— Romans 5:21
Earlier death reigned.
Now grace reigns.
And where does grace lead?
Eternal life.
Through whom?
Jesus Christ our Lord.
That is where Paul's Adam-Christ comparison has been headed.
The Story Is Bigger Than Israel
There is something important about Paul's choice of Adam.
Paul could have continued discussing Abraham.
He could have moved directly to Moses.
Instead, he went back to the first man.
Why?
Because the gospel addresses a problem that began before there was an Israel.
Before circumcision.
Before Sinai.
Before the distinction between Jew and Gentile.
There was humanity.
There was sin.
There was death.
Christ did not come merely to solve an Israel problem.
He came to solve an Adam problem.
That means His work concerns the entire human family.
Jew and Gentile alike live in Adam's world.
And Jew and Gentile alike need the life that comes through Christ.
From Eden to Christ
The Bible's story begins with human beings enjoying life with God.
Then sin enters.
Death follows.
The relationship is broken.
Paul now tells us that Jesus has entered that same story.
Where Adam disobeyed, Christ obeyed.
Where Adam's act brought condemnation, Christ brings justification.
Where Adam's act brought death, Christ brings life.
This helps us see that God's plan of salvation is not an emergency repair added late in the Bible.
It reaches back to humanity's oldest problem.
The gospel is God's answer to Eden.
Read Paul Before Reading a System Into Paul
Romans 5:12–21 has been used in many theological debates.
How is Adam's sin related to us?
What exactly does “made sinners” mean?
What does “all” mean?
Those are legitimate questions.
But before importing later theological systems into the passage, we should first make sure we hear Paul's main contrast.
Paul puts two men before us.
Adam and Christ.
One brought sin, condemnation, and death.
The other brings grace, justification, and life.
And Paul repeatedly tells us that what comes through Christ is “much more.”
Christ is not merely Adam's equal on the other side of the scale.
Grace abounds.
What Has Paul Shown Us So Far?
Paul's argument has been expanding.
In Romans 3, Jew and Gentile were both under sin.
In Romans 4, Paul went back before circumcision and before the Law to Abraham.
Now in Romans 5, he goes back farther still.
All the way to Adam.
The deeper Paul goes into the human story, the clearer his point becomes:
Our deepest problem is not nationality.
It is not whether we possess the Law.
It is not whether we are circumcised.
Our deepest problem is sin and death.
And God's answer is not another human achievement.
God's answer is Jesus Christ our Lord.
Before You Leave
Read Romans 5:12–21 for yourself.
Then make two columns.
At the top of one write:
ADAM
At the top of the other write:
CHRIST
Now go through Paul's paragraph and put his words under the appropriate name.
You will see Paul's argument very quickly.
And then ask:
Is Paul mainly telling the story of one nation — or is he telling the story of the entire human race and what God has done through Christ?
TEXT B4 TRADITION
Read First. Conclude Later.
Questions or comments?
Agree or disagree—we'd like to hear from you. Use the response form on our Home page.